Key takeaways
- Swap “decide” for “discover”. Deciding closes you down. Being willing to discover lets things flow.
- Your purpose starts with who you are, not what you do. Certification is for tools and skills, not for your Apple Tree.
- Don’t pick a niche. Find pockets of people, have sticky conversations, and custom build for the person in front of you.
- Choose one main client attracting style and one backup, and give them 90 days.
“Col, they don’t want what I have.”
A coach I mentor phoned me with that, one week after I’d sent her out to have conversations. She’d spent months agonising over what she wanted to coach. Then she asked the people she wanted to help. They weren’t interested.
To her credit, she’d actually gone and had the conversations. No website, no social media, no funnel. One week, and she knew.
So what’s actually in the way of you finding coaching clients? Even if you’ve got certification, it might not be what you think.
I keep in touch with a core group of 23 to 25 master coaches, some of whom I’ve known for 20 years. I’ve mentored a handful of them closely for the last six or seven years, always asking what’s working and what isn’t. And I’ve wanted certainty thousands of times myself.
This post brings two of my videos together. The first is about the mindset: deciding or discovering. The second is the four client attracting styles I’ve seen work again and again.
What’s really in the way of finding clients?
On the surface, it looks like the problem is deciding. Maybe you picked the wrong niche. Maybe you’re stuck on the decisions you think you need to make before you can move forward. Decision fatigue can keep people stuck for months.
I’ve seen coaches struggle to choose a font, a colour or a logo. I call it faffing with fonts. Their dream of becoming a coach is held to ransom by a simple decision.
So swap the word. Swap decide for discover.
Deciding feels binary. Yes or no. As if the font you pick decides whether your dream lives or dies. Being willing to discover is what I’ve seen actually work.
Notice what happens in your body when you say, “I must decide. I need to decide.” Do you feel open and light? Or heavy, contracted, uncomfortable? That tension is your nervous system’s intuitive way of saying, “I’m not seeing this clearly.” It’s a clue that the pressure to decide could be the very thing in the way.
Now try this:
I’m willing to discover how my purpose wants to express itself.
I’m willing to discover the people who need what I have to offer.
I’m willing to discover what products and programs really work.
I’m willing to discover how to make a living making a difference.
Can you feel what changes? Like a pipe that was closed, it can open, and things can start to flow.
How do the 3 circles work when you discover instead of decide?
My 3 Circles framework has evolved over many decades. It moves through purpose, people and product, and then profit.
When coaches try to decide, it goes like this. I need to decide my purpose. Then I need to decide who needs me, the niche. Then my product or program. Then how I’ll make money. And that decision making closes us down, intuitively.
So let’s discover each one instead.
Why ask “who am I?” before “what should I do?”
When we ask, “What is my life purpose?”, we’re usually trying to decide what to do. That’s the problem: the deciding, and the doing.
Around 27 years ago I had an insight that changed my path, though I didn’t know it at the time. Instead of asking, “What should I do?”, ask, “Who am I?”
I argued. I thought, that’s really not going to help me pay the bills. But the next insight changed everything. If you were an apple tree, and you didn’t know you were an apple tree, how would you know what to do?
It moves the inner furniture around. Being comes first, and doing second. Your purpose is to be your Apple Tree self. Your nature is wired, it has a pattern, a way of expressing itself. When doing comes first, we’re forever trying to decide. Am I doing enough? When being comes first, we discover the many ways we can do from our being.

Skills still matter. If your Apple Tree was an entertainer, it would still be valuable to master your instruments. If your Apple Tree loved nurturing people with food, there’d be wisdom in learning to be a master chef. But no one needs to give you a piece of paper to validate your Apple Tree. Certification is for tools and skills, so you can do more with your being.
At a party, people ask your name, then, “What do you do?” Notice how we answer. We don’t say, “I do coaching.” We say, “I am.” If who you are is based on what you do, you climb into a doing box instead of a discovering one.
Does an apple tree decide how it’s going to grow? No. Here’s a little Col-ism: you don’t need to decide where you’re going if you’re growing.
Think of the moments you thought, this could be my calling. There was no stuttering in the mind. No holding back. You simply spoke, and held space, and it felt as good as an apple tree making apples. Then comes the courage: back your Apple Tree. An Apple Tree doesn’t say, “I’m better than.” It doesn’t say, “I am less than.” It just says, “I am this.”
The day I found my Apple Tree, and was willing to discover how it showed up, everything changed.
Why shouldn’t you pick a niche?
People can’t see you when you can’t see you. People can’t feel your authenticity when you aren’t being authentic. Even increasing your authentic Apple Tree presence by 20% makes a difference to business.
Everyone says, pick a niche. But every master coach whose career I’ve followed, and who’s been successful, isn’t niched. By success I mean making a living making a difference, not only material success. I was surprised too. I thought staying un-niched would only work for me.
The coaches who do well have a big toolbox and flexible skills. When they’re in a room with a certain pocket of people, their Apple Tree can respond. This person needs shade. That person needs apples. You’re not endlessly changing who you are. You’re discovering more ways to serve more people who need you.
We’re not here for everyone. There are certain pockets of people who’d benefit from who you are, and you haven’t found them yet. Think about what gives you energy and inspiration, and the kinds of people you actually care about. Think beyond coaching: your interests, the groups you already belong to. Then go and have natural conversations with those pockets of people.
If you have a charitable nature and care for people who can’t afford to pay you, mix it up. Have at least one or two groups who genuinely can afford you, so you can serve the others in different ways. It’s no good being an apple tree saying to the rain clouds, “Please don’t rain on me.” We want to be apple trees that say yes to the rain.
It’s the same reason I’ve written about not boxing yourself in as a life coach.
How do you discover what to offer?
The coaches who do really well, and I include myself, are willing to discover programs and products instead of deciding them. That includes discovering while we deliver. I call it discovering in the fire of the client experience.
You might say, “Col, I don’t want to wing it.” I’m not telling you to wing it. The people who need your Apple Tree will tell you, directly or indirectly, how to make better apples.
Here’s what no one wants to tell you, and it’s really true. We don’t know yet. We can have some idea. Wanting certainty is in the way of you finding clients. If you’re not certain of your people, your product, or even your purpose, you’re not doing something wrong. That’s the honest place to be.
So take your Apple Tree into rooms, virtual or otherwise, and listen more than you talk. Service means truly being of use, easing suffering in some way. Where are people stuck, struggling, suffering, stressed? Then ask yourself, how could I possibly help?
And we don’t say, “I’m certain I can help you.” We say, “I’m willing to discover if I can help you. Shall we have that conversation?”
Feel the difference. Most coaches are allergic to aggressive, icky selling, and rightly so. “I can help you” is often a false promise. “I think I have something that may be useful. I’d love to have a chat to see if that’s true” isn’t. Then you custom build: “I have these skills, tools and frameworks, and I’m willing to discover which one could help you.” That’s the path that works, especially in the beginning.
About 90% of the coaches I’ve seen succeed have no website, little to no social media, no funnels and no ads. They’re doing exactly this.
When should you focus on profit?
When you see purpose, people and product working together in a pattern, then, and only then, focus on profit. Focusing on profit too early shuts down the flow, because we don’t know yet. And many of us don’t want to be those people. We’re here to make a living making a difference, and to enhance our ability to express our purpose.
When the 3 Circles work, they start to spin business naturally. Then you can decide how to scale it. We give to grow, and we grow to give. That way, you find clients naturally.
The second video turns this into practice: the four client attracting styles.
What are the four client attracting styles?
Over the decades, I’ve watched so many coaches try their best with the mainstream advice. Pick a niche, perfect a product, promote and hope. They get stuck, feel disappointed, and wonder if this isn’t their path. All they needed to do was change the approach.
So I’ve summarised the four client attracting styles I’ve seen show up again and again: conversations, collaborations, content and curiosity. You don’t have to do them all. Choose one main style and a second as a backup. Put 90 days of effort into it, and see what happens. When it starts to teach you, double down.
The first two work particularly well for coaches who enjoy connecting, the people people. Introverts can use them too.
What is a sticky conversation?
I stole the word sticky from website language. I was an early adopter, making some of the first websites in my industry nearly 30 years ago, before coaching was really a profession. A sticky website is one you stay on, not for entertainment, but because it’s relevant. It solves your problem, in a very specific way. If a site is too broad and vague, you click back.
A sticky conversation isn’t a sales conversation. Don’t go and try to sell anything. The point is, you don’t even know what your program is yet. Show up as an actual human being. Keep it casual. And be a little bit obsessed with what would make something sticky for this person. What solution are they looking for, specifically? And how significant is it to them?

The coach who phoned me was interested in prenatal mums and young mothers. I said, “That’s a good place to start, but it could be anyone. I don’t want you to pick a niche. I want you to discover the people who need you. Go and have conversations before you build a website. Don’t sell. Find out what they want.”
A week later came the phone call. “Col, they don’t want what I have.” In casual, low risk conversations, she’d found out. So I said, “Now find out what they do need. And what about other people?”
She started experimenting. She focused on them, and custom built a prototype for the person in front of her, low risk, not charging a lot. Later she told me, “Col, my aha moment was when I realised it’s about them, not me.” It turned her whole early journey around.
Start sapling small. An apple tree doesn’t leap into a fully fruited tree.
Of that core group of 23 to 25 master coaches, many have only ever used conversations, and custom built products. They didn’t find one niche. They found four or five groups. Some coach executives, teenagers and relationships, because they have the tools. Only two ever used social media. One used Instagram for about a year, and then got too busy for it. The other used LinkedIn for a couple of months. None of them get work from websites, funnels or ads. Some have had 15 or 20 successful years from conversations alone.
MASTER COACH TIP: Think about who you were five or ten years ago, and what you were struggling with. Go and find groups where you have common ground, and just chat.
How do collaborations help you find clients?
Collaborations are a natural next step from conversations. Joint ventures and partnerships. You could partner with someone to run small events or big ones, online or offline: dinner parties, demonstrations, talks. You could co-create programs too.
Be careful with co-creating. It raises intellectual property concerns. It’s a terrible thing to say, but we don’t plan for, quote unquote, the divorce. Shared IP gets messy when you try to separate it. So when you’re new, the safest collaborations are events. Start sapling small: five people, ten people. The great thing is, you’re both promoting, and you’re both pulling people in.
Choose someone with the same interests, values and ethics as you, who serves similar people but isn’t a competitor. In my late 20s, I collaborated with someone to speak at a little event. We had different offers, but we guessed our markets were the same. I wasn’t even sure yet who my market was.
And be careful not to see everyone as a competitor. A coach I know specialises in Enneagram plus systemic and family coaching. She’s no threat to other Enneagram coaches, so many of them want to collaborate with her. She’s spoken at conferences because of it.
MASTER COACH TIP: Collaborations suit people who don’t love doing things alone. They multiply your reach. And they still start with conversations.
What makes content work for finding clients?
The last two styles are more traditional. With content, you prove you can help by helping. Online or offline. Little talks and demonstrations count as content too, and they’re easier on the tech pressure.
Content needs consistency. It’s farming. If you were growing an orchard of apple trees, you’d water and nourish them every day, and you wouldn’t expect the orchard to grow in a week. Don’t compare yourself to big content creators. Be gentle with yourself, and start sapling small.
And content needs to be sticky. As useful as possible, and quick to the point, to honour people’s time. Use the words your clients actually use. What would they say on a Friday afternoon, tired, to a friend, over a cup of coffee? “I’m trying to find myself again.” “I’m tired of carrying my team.” “I’m reinventing myself and I don’t know where to start.” Not “how to inspire and motivate yourself to achieve your aspirations”. That’s clever, not clear.
Where do you start? Think in pockets of people. Pick three to five small groups where you care, and where you’re credible. Say you love tennis. People who play tennis want coaches. You belong to a church or a spiritual group? People there want coaches. You enjoy low carb or organic eating? You’re a parent of toddlers? You have corporate leadership experience? You know what I’m going to say. Then drop content into those spaces, around what that group specifically cares about.
MASTER COACH TIP: Care can make you credible. But if you know nothing about tennis, don’t go and talk to people about tennis.
What is the curiosity style, and what’s a lead magnet?
The curiosity style is what’s traditionally called a lead magnet. In my simple Col language: give people a slice of cake to sell the cake.

It’s similar to content, but packaged with intention. Content is small and regular, feeding the orchard. A lead magnet is often built from your winning content. Say you share ten pieces, and one is particularly powerful. People comment, forward it, save it, thank you for it. Upgrade that one into a slice of cake: a little PDF you offer when people comment, or a whole webinar, or a breakfast conversation.
You could build funnels, ads and social campaigns around it. Very few of the coaches I’ve worked with have ever needed to. That’s for scaling what’s already working. And don’t scale until you’ve proven your offer through regular sales and referrals. Those are the two signs I look for.
Which client attracting style should you choose?
Conversations and collaborations go well together. So do content and curiosity. Pick one bundle. Start with conversations that lead to collaborations. Or start with content that leads to curiosity, and a lead magnet you can build out later if you choose.
I’ve seen coaches do this so well that they’re booked out months in advance, and never need funnels at all. Find two or three pockets of people to serve, co-create, and custom build for the person in front of you. It’s a natural way to find clients, instead of pick a niche, perfect a product, promote and hope.
I share more of the Apple Tree on colleen-joy.com.
Which client attracting style feels most natural to you?
The 3 Circles and the four client attracting styles are part of what we teach in our Business Coach Certification. Have a look, or check if there’s a seat and we’re a fit.

